The College Football Playoff semifinals delivered drama and a championship matchup few would have predicted a decade ago: Miami versus Indiana. But beneath the surface of a thrilling postseason lies a system many believe is headed for a correction.

Indiana, a program with almost no gridiron tradition, punched its ticket to the title game by defeating Oregon in the Peach Bowl. Miami, which drew outrage for making the 12-team field, silenced critics by advancing as well. The Hurricanes’ presence in the final reignites the debate over selection criteria, but the on-field product has been undeniable entertainment.

“How is this not fun?” asked columnist Adam Hill in a recent piece, reflecting the sentiment of many fans.

Parity has been fueled by NIL deals, revenue sharing, and the transfer portal, allowing programs outside the traditional power structure to compete for top talent. Gone are the days when a handful of schools hoarded elite recruits. Teams can now spend aggressively to rebuild rosters quickly.

Yet the same forces creating excitement also threaten sustainability. The case of Washington quarterback Demond Williams illustrates the potential pitfalls. Williams tried to enter the transfer portal seeking more money than the nearly $5 million deal he had already signed, leading to threats, accusations, and a last-minute decision to return to the Huskies.

“The cleanup operation just before Mom and Dad get back is never as much fun as making the mess,” Hill wrote.

Rules and guidelines are expected to return, likely favoring traditional powers. The playoff could expand to 16 teams, but mechanisms may be introduced to protect the status quo. For now, fans are urged to enjoy the chaos while it lasts.

“There will be time later to get things in order before Mom and Dad return home,” Hill said.